BC Poverty Reduction Pilot Projects Just More Downloading of Responsibility


Social Development Minister Stephanie Cadieux doing what she does best; cutting costs and calling it innovative poverty reduction initiatives.

I was doing a web search for Canadian news articles with the word poverty in them (usually only takes a few seconds, unfortunately…) when I came across an article which seemed to imply that the BC government was perhaps considering a provincial poverty reduction strategy. Indeed, the title was ‘Surrey chosen to pilot provincial poverty reduction strategy‘. It startled me a bit. Had I slipped into some bizarro backwards world? And why wasn’t this bigger news? Why did it take me three days to find out about it?

It turns out the reality is rather underwhelming. (And the article’s headline incorrect and misleading.)

Here’s what I’ve been able to piece together from 4 online articles and a provincial press release:

There is no funding for this initiative. Ministry consultants already on the payroll are being assigned to work with communities (local government, business, NGOs, etc) to come up with an ‘action plan’, targeted at families with children,
that ‘uses existing resources in each community’.

Basically, the Liberals are sending some bean-counters out into 7 communities (with 20 more to be chosen in the next two years) to help communities make service delivery more efficient.

It sort of makes sense. The government is on a tight budget and are looking at ways of cutting costs. They hear us clambering for more help to reduce poverty, and so, seeing as they don’t want to spend money on poverty, they want to help us make sure we are making the most of what we have. Pretty slick. Good way of not spending a dime on the problem, and yet appearing as if they’ve set out to do something innovative and comprehensive.

NDP Social Development Critic Carol James had this to say: “I worry we’re going to be downloading responsibility to communities,” James said. “It says to communities, ‘you have to talk more, you have to reduce redundancies.’ The community organizations I know have been doing that incredibly well. They’ve had to stretch dollar, they’ve had to find efficiencies to survive.”

It’s going to take a lot more than a new committee and some sharing of resources to end poverty. Do we truly already have the resources we need to end poverty in our communities, but just have not been working together well enough yet?

Maybe so, but not in the sense that the government is implying.

I’m the first to admit that we shouldn’t be looking at a big centralized colonial government to solve all our problems. We could be looking out for each other, sharing resources among ourselves, donating to some innovative anti-poverty programs or helping our friends and neighbours instead of buying that second mocha latte of the day. It sucks that we’re being forced into this, but just complaining is not enough.

The writing is on the wall here. This is the best we can hope for out of the BC Liberals, (and it’ll be better, but far from enough with the NDP in power.)

The trick is in convincing the public that their tax money is not being used to help the poor, and that slowly, dollar by dollar, the responsibility for social services are being downloaded onto communities, and we’ll need to dig deeper into our pockets, or roll up our sleeves and pitch in to help each other.

The social safety net has been slowly eroding for the past twenty years in favour of a flawed neo-liberal idea that smaller, cheaper government will mean more money out in the private market for jobs.

The trickle-down theory is all a bunch of horseshit and the cuts to social services have made life not only harder for the unemployed but for the working poor as well.

The sad truth is that this reality has been building for decades, and even if the political will were to exist with the NDP, this is a very deep hole that the neo-liberal governments have created for us. There are a lot of variables with any of these plans, and a lot is riding on what we, the public, decide to do.

More links:

B.C. targets family poverty in pilot project in Surrey, six other areas

PG Taking Part in Poverty Reduction Strategy

NDP blasts poverty pilot project

One response »

  1. Pingback: Media and Policy News: 2 May 2012

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s